using the arrow buttons.
by clicking on the page.
the page around when zoomed in by dragging it.
the zoom using the slider when zoomed-in.
by clicking on the zoomed-in page.
by entering text in the search field, and select "This Issue" or "All Issues"
by clicking on thumbnails to select pages, and then press the print button.
displays sections with thumbnails and descriptions.
displays a slider of thumbnails. Click on a page to jump.
allows you to browse the full archive.
about your subscription?
Buddhadharma : Spring 2010
buddhadharma: the practitioner’s quarterly spring 2 0 10 8 The American Zen Teachers Association is a pretty small organization, collects no dues, and has no professional staff. Volunteers take up the housekeeping work, mostly organizing the annual conference, maintaining the website, and sitting on the membership committee. By volunteer, I mean being asked with just enough Calvinist-style guilt hang- ing in the air to remind us how much Buddhism is informed by its host cultures. I knew eventually my time would roll around and I would be asked to volunteer on the membership committee. When it happened it wasn’t as awful as I thought it might be. Still, it has its stresses. Among the more interesting, difficult and, frankly, thankless tasks for the committee is to ascertain whether an applicant would generally be recognized as a working Zen teacher by the existing membership, while at the same time resisting a drift into becoming some sort of cre- dentialing agency. As it turns out, for the most part it’s pretty obvious who is in the club and who is not. But not always. We figured out long ago that some kind of criteria needs to be written down or the process can easily degenerate into “Who do you know?” Still, as our tradition reminds us, it’s all one continuous mistake. So, there’s a fairly regular con- versation about those criteria and who we’re missing in its current iteration. For example, at the end of August we voted Sallie Jiko Tisdale into membership. She’s a lay teacher autho- rized by the prominent Soto priest Kyogen Carlson. She’s been around a long time and done serious training, and the bottom line was that it was an easy “yes.” But her application also raised for me how the current version of our AZTA’s written criteria assumes a significant monastic experience. And with that I found myself think- ing about the phenomenon of lay leadership within the Zen mahasangha in the West. For those who visit Western Zen cen- ters, the two most obvious differences between these centers and temples and monasteries in East Asia are the prominence of women and of lay teachers. In Sallie’s case that’s a twofer. Within the world of Buddhism, the ordained sangha has traditionally been the guardian of the dharma. In most places this has been the Vinaya sangha established by the Buddha and his close associates. In Japan this is the bodhisattva priest- hood, which became a distinct ordination model in 807. But whether monastic or priestly, leadership in most schools of Buddhism has been held unequivocally by the ordained. However, the acknowledgment of the lay brother Huineng’s realization in the seventh century introduced dharma transmis- sion rather than ordination as the critical factor for spiritual leadership among the Zen schools. In case 23 of the Wumen- guan, one of the great collections of koan, the head monk Ming confronts the young Huineng and at the end of their exchange, declares, “Lay brother, you are now my teacher.” Huineng would later ordain, but the separation of ordination and transmission had been established. And with it a new vision of what matters most in the transmission of the dharma had appeared. Still, as the normal rule was for the transmission to be handed on from monastic to monastic, in practice this dis- tinction didn’t really mean much until the twentieth century when a number of teachers—Japanese, Korean, and Chinese— started giving dharma transmission to laypeople. Today a significant number of Zen teachers in the West are not ordained as either Vinaya monks or nuns or within the Japanese bodhisattva priesthood. And exactly what this means has turned out to be quite unclear. On the face of it, perhaps it seems obvious. Dharma transmission is about the recognition of stepping away from self and other, of the direct realization of the fundamental matter. It also suggests confidence that the one acknowledged should be able to help others on their way to their own direct insight. But it turns out when people gather together as spiritual com- munities, at least here in the West, they find they also want some- one to fill ministerial functions, roles that were traditionally held by the ordained. The first practical question concerns jukai, or precepts ceremonies. At this point it seems that pretty much any by James ishmael Ford Who’s in the Club? James Ishmael Ford is a Zen priest and Unitarian Universalist minister. he is a teacher with Boundless Way Zen, a network of Zen meditation groups in the eastern United states, and the author of Zen Master Who? A Guide to the People and Stories of Zen. commentary